The Caps couldn't convert on a second power play opportunity shortly thereafter, but seconds after completing their own first successful penalty kill of the night, they doubled their lead on a forechecking goal.
Lars Eller dumped the puck into the Leafs zone, and Toronto defenseman Jake Gardiner went back to pull it off the boards behind his own net. But before he could do so cleanly, Wilson bulldozed him off the puck, leaving it for Eller who fed Brett Connolly in front. Connolly waited out Andersen just a bit, then backhanded it behind him for a 2-0 Washington lead at 12:07 of the middle stanza.
"I just came off the bench, and Willy made a good hit on the forecheck, and kind of made the guy turn it over," recounts Connolly. "I was trying to talk to Lars and let him know that I was in front all alone. It just worked out. I got the puck in a good area, and I made the first move, and it was good to see him go down. It was good to see [Andersen] go down like that. It was good to see that one go in, for sure."
Two nights after they rallied from a 2-0 third-period deficit to force overtime against the Blues in St. Louis, the Leafs set the table for another comeback when Andreas Johnsson scored on a rebound of an Auston Matthews shot at 4:23 of the third, shaving the Caps' lead to 2-1.