The Caps killed off a penalty to start the second, but the Avs evened the score shortly afterwards when Colin Wilson scored on a backhander from just above the top of the paint at 4:13 of the middle period, his second goal against the Caps this season.
While the game was even at 1-1 in the second, Holtby made his best stop of the night, thwarting Wilson's breakaway bid for a third goal against the Caps. Defenseman Dmitry Orlov also came up large defensively, sliding to block a Mikko Rantanen wraparound bid, and Orlov halted the rebound try, too.
Washington restored its lead late in the middle period. The Caps entered Colorado ice on a three-on-two that failed to produce a shot, but Colorado's clearing bid went right to John Carlson's tape. From just above the tops of the circles, Carlson stepped into a drive that eluded Varlamov on the glove side, putting the Caps up 2-1 at 17:42 of the second.
Colorado had a carryover power play to bridge the second and third periods, and the Avs put some offensive-zone heat on the Caps in the immediate aftermath of that extra-man opportunity. The Caps did not have a power play chance on this night, but they did score a critical goal with an extra attacker on the ice during a delayed penalty call.
From the right half wall, Bowey made a brilliant cross-ice feed to Brett Connolly, who got lost in coverage on the weak side. Bowey put in in Connolly's wheelhouse, and the latter pounded a shot past Varlamov to make it a 3-1 game at 5:15 of the third.