The Caps grabbed an early lead, scoring in the game's first half-minute. T.J. Oshie won a right dot draw in Florida ice, and eight seconds and a couple of passes later, John Carlson had his eighth goal of the season. Carlson redirected Michal Kempny's slap pass from the left point past Florida goaltender Sergei Bobrovsky for a 1-0 Washington lead just 25 seconds after the opening face-off.
Florida bounced back quickly, scoring on its first shot of the game before the game was two minutes old. When Caps defenseman Jonas Siegenthaler blew a tired just inside the Washington line, it left Frank Vatrano with a semi-breakaway, and he beat Holtby to tie the game at 1-1 at 1:55 of the first.
Washington wasn't able to do anything with an early power play, and the Panthers took control of the play soon after completing that kill. The Caps went more than 11 and a half minutes without a shot on net in the middle of the first, and in the meantime, old friend Brett Connolly bit the hand that once fed him, giving the Panthers their first lead of the game.
With Connolly parked at the top of the paint, Anton Stralman let go of a low, hard drive from the right point. Connolly got a piece of it, tipping it past Holtby for a 2-1 Florida lead at 14:26 of the first.
Florida wasted little time in adding to its lead in the second period. The Caps left Sasha Barkov unattended in the high slot, and Evgenii Dadonov found him with a perfect feed. Barkov's one-timer made it a 3-1 game just 27 seconds into the second.
Radko Gudas drew a slashing call on Florida's Brian Boyle, giving the Caps a second power play opportunity ahead of the first television timeout in the second, and this time Washington used a familiar formula to pull within a goal of the Cats. From the right circle, Evgeny Kuznetsov sold the idea of a shot to Bobrovsky, then put a perfect cross-ice feed on Alex Ovechkin's tape. The Caps' captain had an easy power-play goal from the office, a virtual empty-netter to make it a 3-2 game at 6:13.