Columbus couldn't score on a 55-second 5-on-3 in the first period while Toronto mostly carried play, then the Leafs took a 1-0 lead at 13:15 as Jordan Frasca found a loose puck in the slot and buried a shot over the shoulder of Greaves. Columbus replied, though, with 20.9 seconds left in the period when third-round pick Stanislav Svozil danced around a defender at 4-on-4 and put the puck on net, with Angle there to swat home the rebound past goalie Keith Petruzzelli.
There were five goals in a topsy-turvy second period, though, with each team claiming and losing the lead. Malatesta buried a rebound of his own shot on a shorthanded breakaway 1:06 into the period to give Columbus the lead, but Toronto's Braeden Kressler scored 28 seconds later on the power play to tie it at 2. Semyon Der-Arguchintsev gave the Leafs the lead again at 5:35 to complete a nice passing play, but Columbus knotted things at 3 at 10:18 when Dunne banked the rebound of Tim Berni's shot into the net off the goalie. Finally, Malatesta tallied again 32 seconds later to give the Jackets a 4-3 lead they'd hold through the rest of the period.
The third period was just as wild, as Columbus grabbed a 4-2 lead when Cole Fonstad scored on a rush just 2:07 into the period. Toronto then got the first of two power-play goals in the frame when Der-Arguchnitsev scored from in front to make it 5-3 with 8:25 left. Columbus appeared to have sealed the deal when Malatesta finished the hat trick when he tipped home a shot by Gerard Keane to make it 6-4 with 7:23 to go, but Nicholas Robertson scored from the slot with 4:21 to go and the Leafs tied it at 6 with just 23.7 seconds left when Joseph Duszak's shot deflected past Greaves.
But a dustup at the final whistle led to a five-minute major for cross-checking on Robertson, giving the Blue Jackets a power play for the length of overtime. Columbus pushed and pushed and finally capitalized in the dying seconds, as Angle's centering pass tipped off a skate and got by Petruzzelli to complete the perfect weekend for Columbus.