Tavares was captain of the New York Islanders for five seasons before signing a seven-year, $77 million contract with the Maple Leafs as a free agent on July 1, 2018. Tavares, defenseman Morgan Rielly and forward Patrick Marleau, a former San Jose Sharks captain who is an unrestricted free agent, were alternate captains with Toronto last season.
"I don't think it would be awkward," Matthews said of being named captain instead of a veteran. "Everybody has the same goal in mind. Everybody wants to contribute in their own way and do what's best for the team. When somebody is ready, (general manager) Kyle [Dubas] and the staff will make a good choice. No matter who it is, you move forward, do your thing and put in the work."
Matthews, who will turn 22 on Sept. 17, had an NHL career-high 73 points (37 goals, 36 assists) in 68 games last season and six points (five goals, one assist) in seven Stanley Cup Playoff games. The No. 1 pick in the 2016 NHL Draft, Matthews has 205 points (111 goals, 94 assists) in 212 regular-season games for the Maple Leafs and 13 points (10 goals, three assists) in 20 playoff games.
"You can always take a step forward, and that area, leadership, is an area where I want to take a step forward and I think the staff and organization wants that too," he said. "But whether I wear a letter -- whether it's a C or an A or nothing -- I don't think it will change what I do, what I'm like, my personality and how I approach the game."
Matthews said he hopes Toronto forward Mitchell Marner, a restricted free agent, has his contract situation resolved soon.
"Obviously, I hope for the best," Matthews said of the 22-year-old. "He's a big part of the team. You hope to have him there as soon as possible. He's an amazing player, an amazing teammate and a good friend, but it's really none of my business. When it gets done, you just hope it gets done as smooth as possible and then you just go from there."