Big-4 First All-Star Team (1921) WCHL First All-Star Team (1922, 1923, 1925) WCHL Second All-Star Team (1924)
Signed as a free agent by Edmonton (WCHL), November 4, 1921. Traded to NY Americans by Edmonton (WHL) with John Morrison and Roy Rickey for $10,000, September 18, 1925.
We think that Randy is a very good coach. Our players think that Randy is a very good coach. We think that he's going to get the most out of this group. With the addition of the two assistants, a bit of a different dynamic, we're very comfortable that this is a quality coaching staff that's going to maximize the potential of this team.
— Maple Leafs GM Dave Nonis on head coach Randy Carlyle and his staff