The Devils are 0-11 this season in shootouts. They are three points out of the Eastern Conference's final wild card spot.
Cory Schneider made 25 saves for New Jersey.
AVALANCHE 3, BLUE JACKETS 2, OT
COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) — Gabriel Landeskog scored twice, including a power-play goal at 4:27 of overtime to help the Avalanche extend their winning streak to four.
With 102 points, Colorado moved three ahead of Chicago for second place in the Central Division.
Cam Atkinson and Comeau scored in the second period for Columbus, which is hanging on to the second wild-card spot and eighth playoff seed in the Eastern Conference.
HURRICANES 4, PENGUINS 1
PITTSBURGH (AP) — Rookie Elias Lindholm scored twice for the first multi-goal game of his career and Carolina denied listless Pittsburgh a chance to wrap up the Metropolitan Division title.
Eric Staal and Justin Faulk also scored for Carolina while Jeff Skinner added two assists. Anton Khudobin stopped 30 shots as the Hurricanes avoided being swept in the season series by Pittsburgh for the first time in 18 years.
Chris Kunitz scored his 35th goal to give Pittsburgh an early lead, but the Penguins crumbled over the final two periods. Sidney Crosby picked up an assist to push his NHL-leading point total to 100, but Carolina held the otherwise potent Pittsburgh offence in check.
Marc-Andre Fleury made 24 saves, but received little help playing behind a sloppy defence.
STARS 5, CAPITALS 0
WASHINGTON (AP) — Tyler Seguin scored his 33rd goal, Dustin Jeffrey got his first two of the season, and Dallas routed Washington in a game between ninth-place teams trying to leapfrog into a playoff spot.
Dallas began the day one point behind the Phoenix Coyotes for the final post-season berth in the Western Conference. The Coyotes hosted Winnipeg later Tuesday.
The Stars have won five of six in their push to make the playoffs for first time since 2008 — the same year the Capitals began streak of post-season appearances that is in danger of coming to an end.
ISLANDERS 4, PANTHERS 2
UNIONDALE, N.Y. (AP) — Josh Bailey had a goal and assist, and New York kept up its strong finish with a victory over Florida.
New York, on the verge of elimination in the Eastern Conference playoff race, quickly bounced back from Quinton Howden's short-handed goal less than two minutes in and sent the Panthers to their fourth straight loss.
MAPLE LEAFS 3, FLAMES 2
TORONTO (AP) — Toronto snapped an eight-game losing streak to remain in the playoff chase.
The two points were the first Toronto picked up since beating Los Angeles on March 13. It put the Leafs at 82 points, still behind Detroit (84) and Columbus (83) in the Eastern Conference wild-card race.