More than a decade past winning the 1984 NCAA title with Bowling Green, he was rebuilding a program in the midst of six straight losing seasons that had gone almost half a century since its last national championship. Rival Boston University, on the other hand, had recently won a historic fourth national title.
So when the Boston Bruins were considering giving their vacant head coaching job to BU boss Jack Parker, a BC alum asked York if he was eager to see Parker leave college hockey.
"Jerry, in a very respectful way said, 'No, I want him to stay. I want to see if we can measure up to BU,'" said Mike Cavanaugh, York's assistant coach at BC since 1995. "At the time, they were the program to emulate. And they happened to be our rival."
So it seemed all too appropriate that, roughly 15 years since that Fenway function, York made hockey history against Parker and Boston University.
A 5-2 BC victory over BU on Saturday night gave York 924 career wins, tying Ron Mason's all-time collegiate record.
After a 4-2 loss playing at BU on Friday night, BC scored four power-play goals in the home-and-home rematch.
The record adds to achievements that include four national championships and nine Hockey East tournaments won since 1999.
But prior to the weekend, in typical York style, he had been thinking only about his team.
"We haven't discussed it [the record] all week. We're focused on our archrival at BU," York told NHL.com. "It's a great rivalry."
Though the two programs have combined for five titles since 2001, the rivalry was decidedly one-sided when York started at BC in 1994. His first BC team won 11 games and it would take time for his first recruiting class to flourish. Through it all, York showed blind faith in his program.
"When he first got to school, I remember him saying, 'We're going to create a beachhead at the Frozen Four every year. We're going to be there every year.' We were freshmen and I remember thinking we weren't very good. And here he is saying we're going to be a national power, not just every few years, but every year," said Chris Masters, a center who was part of York's first few seasons. "Some of us left the meeting thinking, 'What the hell is a beachhead?' But we understood what he meant."
Sure to York's word, those first recruiting classes overcame their initial growing pains and in York's fourth season at BC, the Eagles won the Hockey East title before losing to Red Berenson's Michigan Wolverines in the NCAA tournament final.
Pegula's vision for Penn State is clearPete Jensen - NHL.com Staff Writer
The Buffalo Sabres owner's generosity has forever changed hockey for the Nittany Lions. READ MORE ›
York hasn't looked back, winning six of the past nine Hockey East tourneys and three of the past five national titles. As his name has climbed the all-time wins list, York's been happy to ignore personal accomplishments in favor of team glory.
"He won his 800th game in the NCAA tournament against Minnesota and nobody really made a big deal of that. 850 was the national championship game when we beat Wisconsin, so nobody made a big deal about 850. When he wins 924, I just know he's going to say, ‘Let's go get 925.' That's how he's always been," Cavanaugh said.
"If you look at all the success BC has had in the last 15 years, we've only had one Hobey Baker winner (Mike Mottau, 2000). The only way you can be effective in preaching team goals is if you really believe it yourself. The team wouldn't buy into it if they thought he was after all the accolades. He's clearly not, and they know that."
That team ethic doesn't end when players leave BC, whether it's to continue their hockey careers or join the real world.
When Wayne Wilson, a member of York's national championship squad at Bowling Green, wanted to give coaching a try, York hired him as an assistant, launching a career that would see Wilson become the all-time wins leader at R.I.T. When Wilson's son Stu, a freshman forward at Yale, recently scored a big goal against Denver, York sent a congratulatory text.
"He literally cared about everyone and was very inclusive of everyone. He wouldn't just talk to the bus driver, he would want to know about him. 'How is your family? How are your kids?' That was with everyone," Wilson said. "He's very accessible. We would be talking in the office, and fans would just drop by the office and he would make time for them."
York's balance between order and tenderness has been a trademark for more than 40 years. The 67-year-old asks that his players refrain from wearing jewelry and growing their hair long -- not to enforce his will, but to maintain focus on the team. And on the verge of hockey history -- he can break the wins record Friday at Providence -- he's happy to admit that his players have occasionally taught him something too.
"Nathan Gerbe taught me how to email. You have to stay current," York said. "The players haven't changed much over the decades. They want to play on winning teams. We talk at BC about when you leave, you want to have a diploma in one hand and a ring in the other."