His own agent, Matt Keator, even told the Boston Globe in June, "This isn't someone who is going to step in and play first line in the NHL. He may have to start in Providence (of the American Hockey League)."
Keator was partially correct.
Wheeler isn't a first-line player anywhere, but he is a second-liner in Boston with 30 points through 47 games. He hasn't played a game for the Providence Bruins all season, and unless he gets hurt and needs to go on a rehab assignment there's a good chance he never will.
"From Matt's perspective, he does a good job of deflecting any expectations and that's how I came into camp. I didn't have any expectations," Wheeler, in town for the NHL YoungStars Game presented by Upper Deck, told NHL.com Thursday. "I just wanted to work as hard as I could and show them what I could do and wherever I belonged I had faith they were going to put me in a place where I could succeed. At the end of the day, they felt I could contribute in Boston. Obviously that was a great situation for me."
It's turned out to be a bonanza for the Bruins, too. The Boston Bruins.
Wheeler got the monkey off his back quickly by scoring a goal in his first NHL game. The 6-foot-5, 210-pounder has since upped his total to 14 with 16 assists. His plus-27 rating is not just second best on his team behind all-star Marc Savard, it's second best in the entire NHL.
Bruins coach Claude Julien, who will lead the Eastern Conference Sunday night, has been playing Wheeler primarily on his off wing. A right-handed shot, he's been on the left wing with center David Krejci and right wing Michael Ryder.
"You're seeing a very mature rookie," Bruins General Manager Peter Chiarelli said. "He's adapted to the two-way game very well, which Claude (Julien) demands, and he's adapted from going from the middle to his off wing. All those things, he's handled well and that speaks to his maturity ... if you had asked me if he would have 11 (goals) before Christmas, I would have said no."
Wheeler, who is from Robbinsdale, Minn., agrees that maturity has played a big factor in his rookie success. He's 22-years-old and came into the League after three years, 125 games and 96 points at the University of Minnesota.
He probably wouldn't have been able to handle the attention he got this summer either.
Wheeler was the fifth pick in the 2004 Entry Draft by the Phoenix Coyotes, but he never signed with the desert dogs. He chose to leave college a year early, meaning the Coyotes had 30 days to sign him or risk losing him to free agency, according to the Collective Bargaining Agreement. Instead of signing, Wheeler exercised his right to pick his own team last summer.
Reportedly 20 teams were after him and Wheeler admitted, "It was a little bit overwhelming at times. Definitely some anxiety kicked in." But with Keator's guidance he found the Bruins to be a perfect match.
They liked how they were developing young players like Krejci, Phil Kessel, Milan Lucic and Mark Stuart. Wheeler, they figured, could fall right in line.
How right they were.
"The attention was flattering, but at the same time you don't want to be looked at as the guy who picks out all of the negatives (on certain places)," Wheeler said. "I also needed to do what was in my best interest and my agent did an excellent job of directing me in the right place and showing me where I'd be the best fit. Boston was the best fit for me."
Wheeler has not only blossomed into a reliable point producer for the B's, scoring goals in a variety of ways - in front of the net, on the rush, via one-timers, etc. - he has also taken kindly to his role as a key penalty killer.
Since Patrice Bergeron and Marco Sturm have gone on injured reserve, Julien has entrusted more shorthanded minutes to Wheeler and Krejci. The two, who have obvious chemistry in 5-on-5 situations, have meshed well together in 4-on-5 as well.
"Every time he's on the ice, he seems to make things happen," Julien said. "He's a smart player. Since training camp, he's been getting more and more confident. He's a good player, he's the real deal, and we've said that all along. That's why we kept him."
Contact Dan Rosen at firstname.lastname@example.org