| OVERALL | PLAYER | TEAM | POSITION |
| 1 | Owen Nolan | QUE | R |
| 2 | Petr Nedved | VAN | C |
| 3 | Keith Primeau | DET | C |
| 4 | Mike Ricci | PHI | C |
| 5 | Jaromir Jagr | PIT | R |
| 6 | Scott Scissons | NYI | C |
| 7 | Darryl Sydor | LAK | D |
| 8 | Derian Hatcher | MNS | D |
| 9 | John Slaney | WSH | D |
| 10 | Drake Berehowsky | TOR | D |
| 11 | Trevor Kidd | CGY | G |
| 12 | Turner Stevenson | MTL | R |
| 13 | Michael Stewart | NYR | D |
| 14 | Brad May | BUF | L |
| 15 | Mark Greig | HFD | R |
| 16 | Karl Dykhuis | CHI | D |
| 17 | Scott Allison | EDM | C |
| 18 | Shawn Antoski | VAN | L |
| 19 | Keith Tkachuk | WIN | C |
| 20 | Martin Brodeur | NJD | G |
| 21 | Bryan Smolinski | BOS | C |