| 1st 00:00 | BUF | Faceoff | #63 T. Ennis won against #21 D. Stepan | |
| 1st 00:09 | BUF | Hit | #9 S. Ott hit #6 A. Stralman | |
| 1st 00:26 | BUF | Hit | #9 S. Ott hit #6 A. Stralman | |
| 1st 00:55 | BUF | Shot | #10 C. Ehrhoff Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 01:49 | NYR | Shot | #4 M. Del Zotto Wrist Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 1st 01:52 | BUF | Hit | #36 P. Kaleta hit #44 S. Eminger | |
| 1st 02:37 | NYR | Hit | #41 S. Bickel hit #65 B. Flynn | |
| 1st 03:05 | BUF | Giveaway | #27 A. Pardy | |
| 1st 03:07 | NYR | Shot | #21 D. Stepan Slap Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 1st 03:21 | NYR | Hit | #14 T. Pyatt hit #21 D. Stafford | |
| 1st 03:37 | BUF | Giveaway | #24 R. Regehr | |
| 1st 03:54 | BUF | Faceoff | #63 T. Ennis won against #19 B. Richards | |
| 1st 04:21 | NYR | Hit | #61 R. Nash hit #63 T. Ennis | |
| 1st 04:29 | NYR | Faceoff | #19 B. Richards won against #19 C. Hodgson | |
| 1st 04:40 | NYR | Takeaway | #19 B. Richards | |
| 1st 05:15 | NYR | Giveaway | #22 B. Boyle | |
| 1st 05:43 | NYR | Faceoff | #8 D. Powe won against #12 K. Porter | |
| 1st 06:05 | NYR | Penalty | #41 S. Bickel Boarding against #65 B. Flynn | |
| 1st 06:05 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #29 J. Pominville | |
| 1st 06:21 | BUF | Shot | #10 C. Ehrhoff Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 06:21 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #29 J. Pominville | |
| 1st 07:08 | NYR | Takeaway | #8 D. Powe | |
| 1st 07:16 | NYR | Shot | #15 J. Halpern Snap Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 1st 08:18 | BUF | Faceoff | #12 K. Porter won against #19 B. Richards | |
| 1st 08:39 | BUF | Hit | #12 K. Porter hit #44 S. Eminger | |
| 1st 09:42 | NYR | Hit | #27 R. McDonagh hit #25 M. Grigorenko | |
| 1st 09:50 | BUF | Penalty | #27 A. Pardy Interference against #24 R. Callahan | |
| 1st 09:50 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #19 C. Hodgson | |
| 1st 09:57 | BUF | Faceoff | #19 C. Hodgson won against #21 D. Stepan | |
| 1st 10:19 | BUF | Hit | #6 M. Weber hit #21 D. Stepan | |
| 1st 10:28 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #24 R. Regehr | |
| 1st 10:34 | NYR | Shot | #4 M. Del Zotto Slap Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 1st 11:12 | NYR | Shot | #19 B. Richards Wrist Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 1st 11:16 | NYR | Shot | #19 B. Richards Wrist Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 1st 12:04 | NYR | Faceoff | #47 J. Miller won against #9 S. Ott | |
| 1st 12:47 | BUF | Hit | #9 S. Ott hit #5 D. Girardi | |
| 1st 13:10 | NYR | Hit | #8 D. Powe hit #24 R. Regehr | |
| 1st 13:43 | BUF | Faceoff | #25 M. Grigorenko won against #19 B. Richards | |
| 1st 14:13 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #19 C. Hodgson | |
| 1st 15:18 | NYR | Giveaway | #27 R. McDonagh | |
| 1st 15:22 | NYR | Faceoff | #19 B. Richards won against #9 S. Ott | |
| 1st 15:41 | NYR | Hit | #6 A. Stralman hit #9 S. Ott | |
| 1st 15:48 | BUF | Shot | #63 T. Ennis Tip-In saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 16:13 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #24 R. Regehr | |
| 1st 16:32 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #36 P. Kaleta | |
| 1st 17:06 | NYR | Faceoff | #8 D. Powe won against #25 M. Grigorenko | |
| 1st 17:29 | BUF | Faceoff | #19 C. Hodgson won against #22 B. Boyle | |
| 1st 17:35 | NYR | Hit | #47 J. Miller hit #10 C. Ehrhoff | |
| 1st 18:00 | BUF | Shot | #29 J. Pominville Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 18:29 | NYR | Takeaway | #27 R. McDonagh | |
| 1st 18:34 | NYR | Shot | #19 B. Richards Slap Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 1st 19:09 | BUF | Faceoff | #19 C. Hodgson won against #21 D. Stepan | |
| 1st 19:48 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #24 R. Regehr | |
| 1st 20:00 | | | Period End | |
| 2nd 00:00 | BUF | Faceoff | #63 T. Ennis won against #21 D. Stepan | |
| 2nd 00:32 | NYR | Faceoff | #19 B. Richards won against #9 S. Ott | |
| 2nd 01:14 | NYR | Hit | #5 D. Girardi hit #9 S. Ott | |
| 2nd 01:20 | BUF | Shot | #29 J. Pominville Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 02:06 | NYR | Hit | #62 C. Hagelin hit #57 T. Myers | |
| 2nd 02:12 | BUF | Hit | #57 T. Myers hit #62 C. Hagelin | |
| 2nd 02:19 | NYR | Hit | #22 B. Boyle hit #10 C. Ehrhoff | |
| 2nd 02:23 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #12 K. Porter | |
| 2nd 02:57 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #27 A. Pardy | |
| 2nd 02:59 | BUF | Shot | #65 B. Flynn Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 03:15 | BUF | Hit | #12 K. Porter hit #24 R. Callahan | |
| 2nd 03:29 | NYR | Shot | #44 S. Eminger Snap Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 2nd 03:30 | NYR | Faceoff | #8 D. Powe won against #25 M. Grigorenko | |
| 2nd 03:39 | BUF | Hit | #24 R. Regehr hit #5 D. Girardi | |
| 2nd 05:18 | NYR | Takeaway | #6 A. Stralman | |
| 2nd 05:22 | NYR | Giveaway | #6 A. Stralman | |
| 2nd 05:30 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #19 C. Hodgson | |
| 2nd 05:30 | BUF | Shot | #6 M. Weber Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 05:40 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #19 C. Hodgson | |
| 2nd 05:55 | BUF | Hit | #6 M. Weber hit #21 D. Stepan | |
| 2nd 06:00 | NYR | Shot | #24 R. Callahan Slap Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 2nd 06:07 | NYR | Takeaway | #14 T. Pyatt | |
| 2nd 06:30 | NYR | Hit | #44 S. Eminger hit #82 M. Foligno | |
| 2nd 06:49 | NYR | Shot | #47 J. Miller Snap Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 2nd 07:16 | BUF | Hit | #36 P. Kaleta hit #4 M. Del Zotto | |
| 2nd 07:30 | BUF | Shot | #10 C. Ehrhoff Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 07:47 | BUF | Shot | #57 T. Myers Wrap-Around saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 08:01 | NYR | Faceoff | #19 B. Richards won against #25 M. Grigorenko | |
| 2nd 08:04 | BUF | Goal | #21 D. Stafford (2) Snap Shot, Assists: #25 M. Grigorenko (4) | |
| 2nd 08:04 | NYR | Faceoff | #19 B. Richards won against #63 T. Ennis | |
| 2nd 08:14 | BUF | Hit | #9 S. Ott hit #44 S. Eminger | |
| 2nd 08:39 | NYR | Hit | #62 C. Hagelin hit #44 A. Sekera | |
| 2nd 08:42 | NYR | Shot | #61 R. Nash Backhand saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 2nd 08:51 | NYR | Faceoff | #8 D. Powe won against #55 J. Hecht | |
| 2nd 09:02 | BUF | Hit | #21 D. Stafford hit #6 A. Stralman | |
| 2nd 09:24 | NYR | Hit | #6 A. Stralman hit #25 M. Grigorenko | |
| 2nd 09:45 | BUF | Hit | #27 A. Pardy hit #15 J. Halpern | |
| 2nd 10:04 | NYR | Hit | #5 D. Girardi hit #82 M. Foligno | |
| 2nd 10:22 | NYR | Hit | #14 T. Pyatt hit #57 T. Myers | |
| 2nd 10:46 | BUF | Shot | #57 T. Myers Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 10:46 | NYR | Faceoff | #19 B. Richards won against #12 K. Porter | |
| 2nd 11:08 | NYR | Faceoff | #22 B. Boyle won against #63 T. Ennis | |
| 2nd 11:35 | BUF | Hit | #44 A. Sekera hit #14 T. Pyatt | |
| 2nd 11:36 | NYR | Shot | #14 T. Pyatt Tip-In saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 2nd 12:01 | NYR | Giveaway | #27 R. McDonagh | |
| 2nd 12:03 | BUF | Shot | #42 N. Gerbe Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 12:05 | BUF | Shot | #9 S. Ott Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 12:06 | BUF | Faceoff | #12 K. Porter won against #19 B. Richards | |
| 2nd 12:12 | BUF | Shot | #36 P. Kaleta Backhand saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 12:52 | BUF | Hit | #12 K. Porter hit #61 R. Nash | |
| 2nd 12:56 | NYR | Shot | #62 C. Hagelin Wrist Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 2nd 12:56 | BUF | Faceoff | #19 C. Hodgson won against #21 D. Stepan | |
| 2nd 14:39 | BUF | Takeaway | #21 D. Stafford | |
| 2nd 15:45 | NYR | Giveaway | #27 R. McDonagh | |
| 2nd 15:48 | BUF | Shot | #65 B. Flynn Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 15:59 | NYR | Shot | #62 C. Hagelin Wrist Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 2nd 16:24 | BUF | Faceoff | #19 C. Hodgson won against #21 D. Stepan | |
| 2nd 16:47 | NYR | Penalty | #18 M. Staal Hooking against #82 M. Foligno | |
| 2nd 16:47 | NYR | Faceoff | #22 B. Boyle won against #9 S. Ott | |
| 2nd 16:57 | BUF | Shot | #10 C. Ehrhoff Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 17:00 | BUF | Shot | #21 D. Stafford Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 17:41 | NYR | Hit | #5 D. Girardi hit #63 T. Ennis | |
| 2nd 17:57 | NYR | Shot | #15 J. Halpern Backhand saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 2nd 18:06 | BUF | Shot | #57 T. Myers Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 18:06 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #19 C. Hodgson | |
| 2nd 18:16 | BUF | Faceoff | #19 C. Hodgson won against #21 D. Stepan | |
| 2nd 18:53 | NYR | Takeaway | #61 R. Nash | |
| 2nd 19:48 | NYR | Shot | #18 M. Staal Slap Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 2nd 19:57 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #12 K. Porter | |
| 2nd 20:00 | | | Period End | |
| 3rd 00:00 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #63 T. Ennis | |
| 3rd 00:49 | NYR | Faceoff | #19 B. Richards won against #19 C. Hodgson | |
| 3rd 01:37 | BUF | Hit | #36 P. Kaleta hit #24 R. Callahan | |
| 3rd 01:46 | NYR | Shot | #24 R. Callahan Snap Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 3rd 02:03 | BUF | Hit | #6 M. Weber hit #24 R. Callahan | |
| 3rd 02:12 | BUF | Hit | #12 K. Porter hit #44 S. Eminger | |
| 3rd 02:22 | NYR | Shot | #22 B. Boyle Slap Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 3rd 02:55 | BUF | Penalty | #44 A. Sekera Hooking against #47 J. Miller | |
| 3rd 02:55 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #9 S. Ott | |
| 3rd 03:28 | BUF | Penalty | #36 P. Kaleta Checking from behind against #19 B. Richards served by #25 M. Grigorenko | |
| 3rd 03:28 | BUF | Penalty | #36 P. Kaleta Game misconduct against #19 B. Richards | |
| 3rd 03:28 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #29 J. Pominville | |
| 3rd 03:35 | NYR | Goal | #21 D. Stepan (5) Slap Shot, Assists: #61 R. Nash (11), #10 M. Gaborik (6) | |
| 3rd 03:35 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #19 C. Hodgson | |
| 3rd 04:18 | NYR | Goal | #61 R. Nash (5) Snap Shot, Assists: #10 M. Gaborik (7), #4 M. Del Zotto (6) | |
| 3rd 04:18 | BUF | Faceoff | #12 K. Porter won against #47 J. Miller | |
| 3rd 04:49 | BUF | Takeaway | #12 K. Porter | |
| 3rd 05:07 | BUF | Faceoff | #19 C. Hodgson won against #21 D. Stepan | |
| 3rd 06:08 | NYR | Giveaway | #10 M. Gaborik | |
| 3rd 06:33 | NYR | Shot | #47 J. Miller Snap Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 3rd 07:23 | NYR | Takeaway | #18 M. Staal | |
| 3rd 07:40 | NYR | Shot | #47 J. Miller Wrist Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 3rd 07:57 | BUF | Shot | #6 M. Weber Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 3rd 08:19 | BUF | Goal | #42 N. Gerbe (3) Snap Shot, Assists: #9 S. Ott (8) | |
| 3rd 08:19 | BUF | Faceoff | #63 T. Ennis won against #22 B. Boyle | |
| 3rd 08:43 | NYR | Takeaway | #22 B. Boyle | |
| 3rd 09:04 | BUF | Hit | #27 A. Pardy hit #10 M. Gaborik | |
| 3rd 09:25 | NYR | Shot | #18 M. Staal Wrist Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 3rd 09:28 | NYR | Shot | #18 M. Staal Backhand saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 3rd 09:47 | BUF | Shot | #82 M. Foligno Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 3rd 10:29 | BUF | Takeaway | #44 A. Sekera | |
| 3rd 11:12 | NYR | Hit | #47 J. Miller hit #6 M. Weber | |
| 3rd 11:15 | BUF | Shot | #25 M. Grigorenko Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 3rd 11:50 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #63 T. Ennis | |
| 3rd 12:47 | NYR | Faceoff | #22 B. Boyle won against #12 K. Porter | |
| 3rd 13:20 | BUF | Faceoff | #19 C. Hodgson won against #21 D. Stepan | |
| 3rd 14:00 | BUF | Hit | #9 S. Ott hit #14 T. Pyatt | |
| 3rd 14:17 | BUF | Hit | #63 T. Ennis hit #27 R. McDonagh | |
| 3rd 14:38 | NYR | Shot | #62 C. Hagelin Tip-In saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 3rd 14:38 | BUF | Faceoff | #12 K. Porter won against #19 B. Richards | |
| 3rd 15:01 | NYR | Shot | #27 R. McDonagh Snap Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| 3rd 15:03 | NYR | Penalty | #61 R. Nash Hooking against #12 K. Porter | |
| 3rd 15:03 | NYR | Faceoff | #22 B. Boyle won against #21 D. Stafford | |
| 3rd 15:09 | BUF | Hit | #9 S. Ott hit #5 D. Girardi | |
| 3rd 15:17 | BUF | Shot | #9 S. Ott Tip-In saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 3rd 15:17 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #63 T. Ennis | |
| 3rd 16:10 | NYR | Takeaway | #15 J. Halpern | |
| 3rd 16:21 | BUF | Giveaway | #42 N. Gerbe | |
| 3rd 16:37 | BUF | Giveaway | #42 N. Gerbe | |
| 3rd 18:20 | NYR | Giveaway | #5 D. Girardi | |
| 3rd 18:27 | BUF | Hit | #9 S. Ott hit #14 T. Pyatt | |
| 3rd 18:49 | BUF | Hit | #82 M. Foligno hit #47 J. Miller | |
| 3rd 18:59 | BUF | Faceoff | #19 C. Hodgson won against #19 B. Richards | |
| 3rd 19:26 | NYR | Penalty | #61 R. Nash Delaying Game - Puck over glass against #29 J. Pominville | |
| 3rd 19:26 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #9 S. Ott | |
| 3rd 20:00 | | | Period End | |
| OT 00:00 | NYR | Faceoff | #24 R. Callahan won against #9 S. Ott | |
| OT 00:22 | BUF | Shot | #29 J. Pominville Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| OT 00:29 | BUF | Shot | #10 C. Ehrhoff Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| OT 00:54 | NYR | Penalty | #5 D. Girardi Boarding against #63 T. Ennis | |
| OT 00:54 | NYR | Faceoff | #21 D. Stepan won against #19 C. Hodgson | |
| OT 01:12 | BUF | Shot | #29 J. Pominville Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| OT 01:12 | BUF | Faceoff | #9 S. Ott won against #21 D. Stepan | |
| OT 01:37 | BUF | Shot | #63 T. Ennis Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| OT 01:56 | NYR | Faceoff | #22 B. Boyle won against #25 M. Grigorenko | |
| OT 02:23 | BUF | Shot | #10 C. Ehrhoff Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| OT 02:26 | BUF | Shot | #25 M. Grigorenko Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| OT 02:26 | BUF | Faceoff | #25 M. Grigorenko won against #21 D. Stepan | |
| OT 02:36 | BUF | Shot | #42 N. Gerbe Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| OT 02:43 | NYR | Shot | #21 D. Stepan Wrist Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| OT 03:53 | NYR | Shot | #61 R. Nash Wrist Shot saved by #30 R. Miller | |
| OT 04:37 | NYR | Faceoff | #19 B. Richards won against #29 J. Pominville | |
| OT 05:00 | | | Period End | |
| Shootout | NYR | Goal | #61 R. Nash - Backhand | |
| Shootout | BUF | Shot | #29 J. Pominville Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| Shootout | NYR | Goal | #24 R. Callahan - Wrist Shot | |
| Shootout | BUF | Shot | #63 T. Ennis Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| Shootout | | | Shootout Complete | |