| 1st 00:19 | NYR | Hit | #8 B. Prust hit #48 T. Kennedy | |
| 1st 01:53 | NYR | Hit | #21 D. Stepan hit #7 P. Martin | |
| 1st 02:22 | NYR | Hit | #97 M. Gilroy hit #17 M. Rupp | |
| 1st 02:31 | NYR | Hit | #4 M. Del Zotto hit #25 M. Talbot | |
| 1st 02:57 | PIT | Hit | #45 A. Asham hit #23 C. Drury | |
| 1st 03:22 | PIT | Hit | #58 K. Letang hit #45 K. Newbury | |
| 1st 03:52 | NYR | Goal | #8 B. Prust (8) Snap Shot, Assists: #86 W. Wolski (15), #22 B. Boyle (10) | |
| 1st 04:15 | PIT | Shot | #11 J. Staal Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 04:24 | NYR | Hit | #4 M. Del Zotto hit #9 P. Dupuis | |
| 1st 04:52 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #14 C. Kunitz | |
| 1st 05:08 | PIT | Hit | #15 D. Jeffrey hit #38 M. Sauer | |
| 1st 05:31 | PIT | Hit | #17 M. Rupp hit #38 M. Sauer | |
| 1st 05:42 | PIT | Shot | #17 M. Rupp Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 05:55 | NYR | Hit | #27 R. McDonagh hit #18 C. Conner | |
| 1st 05:55 | PIT | Shot | #25 M. Talbot Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 05:57 | PIT | Penalty | #18 C. Conner Tripping against #8 B. Prust | |
| 1st 06:42 | PIT | Hit | #25 M. Talbot hit #18 M. Staal | |
| 1st 07:17 | PIT | Hit | #24 M. Cooke hit #97 M. Gilroy | |
| 1st 08:16 | PIT | Shot | #9 P. Dupuis Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 08:30 | PIT | Shot | #3 A. Goligoski Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 08:41 | PIT | Shot | #48 T. Kennedy Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 09:15 | PIT | Shot | #14 C. Kunitz Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 09:20 | PIT | Hit | #58 K. Letang hit #42 A. Anisimov | |
| 1st 09:29 | PIT | Hit | #44 B. Orpik hit #42 A. Anisimov | |
| 1st 09:52 | NYR | Hit | #17 B. Dubinsky hit #9 P. Dupuis | |
| 1st 10:16 | PIT | Hit | #17 M. Rupp hit #4 M. Del Zotto | |
| 1st 10:20 | PIT | Shot | #4 Z. Michalek Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 10:25 | PIT | Hit | #25 M. Talbot hit #21 D. Stepan | |
| 1st 10:29 | NYR | Shot | #97 M. Gilroy Wrist Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 1st 11:11 | NYR | Shot | #22 B. Boyle Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 1st 12:09 | PIT | Shot | #28 E. Godard Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 12:09 | PIT | Hit | #27 C. Adams hit #97 M. Gilroy | |
| 1st 12:17 | PIT | Shot | #27 C. Adams Tip-In saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 12:48 | NYR | Shot | #21 D. Stepan Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 1st 14:20 | NYR | Shot | #42 A. Anisimov Wrist Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 1st 14:27 | NYR | Hit | #5 D. Girardi hit #24 M. Cooke | |
| 1st 15:02 | NYR | Hit | #4 M. Del Zotto hit #48 T. Kennedy | |
| 1st 15:41 | NYR | Hit | #86 W. Wolski hit #58 K. Letang | |
| 1st 16:03 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #58 K. Letang | |
| 1st 16:04 | NYR | Shot | #24 R. Callahan Tip-In saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 1st 16:23 | NYR | Shot | #27 R. McDonagh Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 1st 16:31 | PIT | Hit | #17 M. Rupp hit #38 M. Sauer | |
| 1st 16:46 | PIT | Shot | #27 C. Adams Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 17:49 | NYR | Shot | #17 B. Dubinsky Slap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 1st 18:33 | PIT | Hit | #27 C. Adams hit #97 M. Gilroy | |
| 1st 19:37 | PIT | Hit | #58 K. Letang hit #16 S. Avery | |
| 1st 19:59 | PIT | Shot | #15 D. Jeffrey Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 20:00 | | | Period End | |
| 2nd 00:42 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #58 K. Letang | |
| 2nd 00:50 | NYR | Shot | #21 D. Stepan Tip-In saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 2nd 00:58 | NYR | Hit | #17 B. Dubinsky hit #5 D. Engelland | |
| 2nd 01:03 | PIT | Hit | #5 D. Engelland hit #10 M. Gaborik | |
| 2nd 01:27 | PIT | Shot | #11 J. Staal Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 01:39 | NYR | Shot | #10 M. Gaborik Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 2nd 01:41 | NYR | Goal | #42 A. Anisimov (11) Snap Shot, Assists: #17 B. Dubinsky (22), #10 M. Gaborik (16) | |
| 2nd 01:57 | PIT | Shot | #27 C. Adams Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 02:12 | NYR | Hit | #23 C. Drury hit #44 B. Orpik | |
| 2nd 02:20 | PIT | Shot | #25 M. Talbot Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 02:41 | PIT | Hit | #44 B. Orpik hit #16 S. Avery | |
| 2nd 02:53 | NYR | Hit | #38 M. Sauer hit #9 P. Dupuis | |
| 2nd 03:10 | NYR | Hit | #38 M. Sauer hit #9 P. Dupuis | |
| 2nd 03:17 | PIT | Shot | #3 A. Goligoski Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 03:17 | NYR | Penalty | #8 B. Prust Fighting against #5 D. Engelland | |
| 2nd 03:17 | PIT | Penalty | #5 D. Engelland Fighting against #8 B. Prust | |
| 2nd 04:44 | NYR | Hit | #17 B. Dubinsky hit #15 D. Jeffrey | |
| 2nd 04:59 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #44 B. Orpik | |
| 2nd 05:18 | NYR | Shot | #16 S. Avery Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 2nd 05:20 | NYR | Penalty | #45 K. Newbury Elbowing against #29 M. Fleury | |
| 2nd 05:30 | PIT | Goal | #15 D. Jeffrey (3) Slap Shot, Assists: #14 C. Kunitz (18), #3 A. Goligoski (18) | |
| 2nd 06:20 | NYR | Hit | #5 D. Girardi hit #24 M. Cooke | |
| 2nd 06:37 | NYR | Hit | #18 M. Staal hit #18 C. Conner | |
| 2nd 06:38 | PIT | Shot | #18 C. Conner Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 07:21 | PIT | Hit | #17 M. Rupp hit #27 R. McDonagh | |
| 2nd 07:28 | NYR | Shot | #21 D. Stepan Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 2nd 09:35 | PIT | Hit | #11 J. Staal hit #5 D. Girardi | |
| 2nd 09:43 | PIT | Shot | #5 D. Engelland Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 10:36 | PIT | Goal | #17 M. Rupp (5) Snap Shot, Assists: #25 M. Talbot (7), #5 D. Engelland (5) | |
| 2nd 10:56 | NYR | Penalty | #21 D. Stepan Holding against #7 P. Martin | |
| 2nd 12:17 | PIT | Hit | #14 C. Kunitz hit #17 B. Dubinsky | |
| 2nd 12:57 | PIT | Hit | #17 M. Rupp hit #5 D. Girardi | |
| 2nd 13:12 | PIT | Hit | #58 K. Letang hit #21 D. Stepan | |
| 2nd 13:24 | PIT | Hit | #58 K. Letang hit #36 M. Zuccarello | |
| 2nd 13:33 | PIT | Hit | #9 P. Dupuis hit #5 D. Girardi | |
| 2nd 14:12 | PIT | Goal | #14 C. Kunitz (17) Tip-In, Assists: #4 Z. Michalek (8), #44 B. Orpik (10) | |
| 2nd 14:36 | PIT | Shot | #9 P. Dupuis Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 14:48 | NYR | Hit | #17 B. Dubinsky hit #4 Z. Michalek | |
| 2nd 15:27 | PIT | Penalty | #11 J. Staal Match penalty against #8 B. Prust | |
| 2nd 18:12 | NYR | Shot | #24 R. Callahan Slap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 2nd 18:24 | NYR | Shot | #22 B. Boyle Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 2nd 19:11 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #58 K. Letang | |
| 2nd 19:47 | NYR | Goal | #24 R. Callahan (11) Tip-In, Assists: #4 M. Del Zotto (8), #36 M. Zuccarello (9) | |
| 2nd 20:00 | | | Period End | |
| 3rd 00:30 | NYR | Shot | #42 A. Anisimov Tip-In saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 3rd 00:49 | PIT | Hit | #44 B. Orpik hit #17 B. Dubinsky | |
| 3rd 01:29 | NYR | Penalty | #17 B. Dubinsky Hi-sticking against #58 K. Letang | |
| 3rd 02:16 | NYR | Shot | #21 D. Stepan Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 3rd 03:05 | NYR | Hit | #5 D. Girardi hit #15 D. Jeffrey | |
| 3rd 04:01 | NYR | Shot | #23 C. Drury Slap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 3rd 04:26 | NYR | Hit | #16 S. Avery hit #48 T. Kennedy | |
| 3rd 04:51 | PIT | Hit | #24 M. Cooke hit #97 M. Gilroy | |
| 3rd 05:25 | NYR | Shot | #18 M. Staal Snap Shot | |
| 3rd 06:52 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #17 M. Rupp | |
| 3rd 07:03 | PIT | Hit | #25 M. Talbot hit #38 M. Sauer | |
| 3rd 07:30 | PIT | Hit | #17 M. Rupp hit #36 M. Zuccarello | |
| 3rd 07:59 | NYR | Hit | #4 M. Del Zotto hit #48 T. Kennedy | |
| 3rd 08:22 | NYR | Hit | #4 M. Del Zotto hit #48 T. Kennedy | |
| 3rd 08:40 | PIT | Hit | #44 B. Orpik hit #86 W. Wolski | |
| 3rd 08:50 | PIT | Hit | #24 M. Cooke hit #18 M. Staal | |
| 3rd 09:28 | NYR | Hit | #18 M. Staal hit #9 P. Dupuis | |
| 3rd 10:14 | PIT | Hit | #7 P. Martin hit #16 S. Avery | |
| 3rd 10:21 | NYR | Shot | #16 S. Avery Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 3rd 10:32 | NYR | Shot | #24 R. Callahan Slap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 3rd 10:54 | PIT | Shot | #14 C. Kunitz Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 3rd 11:06 | NYR | Shot | #22 B. Boyle Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 3rd 12:20 | PIT | Hit | #58 K. Letang hit #21 D. Stepan | |
| 3rd 12:39 | NYR | Shot | #42 A. Anisimov Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 3rd 12:41 | PIT | Hit | #44 B. Orpik hit #17 B. Dubinsky | |
| 3rd 12:46 | NYR | Shot | #18 M. Staal Backhand saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 3rd 12:46 | PIT | Penalty | #58 K. Letang Cross checking against #24 R. Callahan | |
| 3rd 13:15 | PIT | Hit | #4 Z. Michalek hit #24 R. Callahan | |
| 3rd 14:27 | NYR | Shot | #18 M. Staal Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 3rd 15:32 | NYR | Shot | #16 S. Avery Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| 3rd 16:02 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #44 B. Orpik | |
| 3rd 16:08 | NYR | Hit | #42 A. Anisimov hit #58 K. Letang | |
| 3rd 16:15 | NYR | Hit | #18 M. Staal hit #25 M. Talbot | |
| 3rd 18:02 | PIT | Shot | #7 P. Martin Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 3rd 18:12 | NYR | Hit | #8 B. Prust hit #4 Z. Michalek | |
| 3rd 19:06 | PIT | Hit | #44 B. Orpik hit #42 A. Anisimov | |
| 3rd 19:26 | NYR | Hit | #22 B. Boyle hit #58 K. Letang | |
| 3rd 19:46 | PIT | Shot | #25 M. Talbot Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 3rd 19:59 | NYR | Hit | #22 B. Boyle hit #58 K. Letang | |
| 3rd 20:00 | | | Period End | |
| OT 01:15 | PIT | Hit | #44 B. Orpik hit #17 B. Dubinsky | |
| OT 02:02 | NYR | Shot | #21 D. Stepan Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| OT 03:21 | NYR | Hit | #22 B. Boyle hit #15 D. Jeffrey | |
| OT 04:07 | PIT | Shot | #48 T. Kennedy Snap Shot | |
| OT 04:30 | PIT | Hit | #15 D. Jeffrey hit #17 B. Dubinsky | |
| OT 04:34 | NYR | Shot | #5 D. Girardi Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| OT 05:00 | | | Period End | |
| Shootout | PIT | Shot | #58 K. Letang Snap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| Shootout | NYR | Shot | #86 W. Wolski Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| Shootout | PIT | Missed | #9 P. Dupuis - Over Net | |
| Shootout | NYR | Shot | #36 M. Zuccarello Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| Shootout | PIT | Shot | #14 C. Kunitz Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| Shootout | NYR | Shot | #42 A. Anisimov Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| Shootout | PIT | Missed | #48 T. Kennedy - Wide of Net | |
| Shootout | PIT | Missed | #3 A. Goligoski - Wide of Net | |
| Shootout | NYR | Shot | #21 D. Stepan Backhand saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| Shootout | PIT | Shot | #18 C. Conner Backhand saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| Shootout | NYR | Shot | #17 B. Dubinsky Backhand saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| Shootout | PIT | Goal | #15 D. Jeffrey - Snap Shot | |
| Shootout | NYR | Shot | #10 M. Gaborik Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |
| Shootout | NYR | Shot | #24 R. Callahan Snap Shot saved by #29 M. Fleury | |