| 1st 00:47 | NYR | Hit | #10 M. Gaborik hit #22 F. Beauchemin | |
| 1st 01:05 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #3 D. Phaneuf | |
| 1st 01:54 | TOR | Penalty | #32 K. Versteeg Interference against #17 B. Dubinsky | |
| 1st 02:21 | NYR | Shot | #21 D. Stepan Snap Shot saved by #35 J. Giguere | |
| 1st 03:40 | NYR | Hit | #16 S. Avery hit #9 C. Armstrong | |
| 1st 04:19 | TOR | Shot | #37 T. Brent Wrist Shot | |
| 1st 04:26 | TOR | Shot | #3 D. Phaneuf Slap Shot | |
| 1st 05:00 | TOR | Shot | #81 P. Kessel Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 05:10 | TOR | Shot | #84 M. Grabovski Wrist Shot | |
| 1st 05:20 | NYR | Hit | #42 A. Anisimov hit #16 C. MacArthur | |
| 1st 05:35 | TOR | Shot | #41 N. Kulemin Backhand | |
| 1st 06:09 | NYR | Hit | #97 M. Gilroy hit #28 C. Orr | |
| 1st 06:40 | TOR | Hit | #11 F. Sjostrom hit #33 M. Rozsival | |
| 1st 06:46 | TOR | Shot | #3 D. Phaneuf Slap Shot | |
| 1st 06:58 | TOR | Hit | #11 F. Sjostrom hit #97 M. Gilroy | |
| 1st 07:06 | NYR | Shot | #21 D. Stepan Backhand | |
| 1st 07:08 | TOR | Hit | #22 F. Beauchemin hit #21 D. Stepan | |
| 1st 07:15 | TOR | Shot | #11 F. Sjostrom Snap Shot | |
| 1st 07:22 | TOR | Hit | #11 F. Sjostrom hit #16 S. Avery | |
| 1st 07:32 | NYR | Hit | #19 R. Fedotenko hit #36 C. Gunnarsson | |
| 1st 07:58 | NYR | Goal | #33 M. Rozsival (1) Wrist Shot, Assists: #16 S. Avery (3), #19 R. Fedotenko (1) | |
| 1st 08:25 | NYR | Shot | #42 A. Anisimov Wrist Shot | |
| 1st 09:00 | TOR | Penalty | #16 C. MacArthur Slashing against #44 S. Eminger | |
| 1st 09:19 | TOR | Hit | #2 L. Schenn hit #42 A. Anisimov | |
| 1st 09:56 | NYR | Shot | #24 R. Callahan Backhand saved by #35 J. Giguere | |
| 1st 10:16 | TOR | Hit | #2 L. Schenn hit #42 A. Anisimov | |
| 1st 10:17 | NYR | Shot | #24 R. Callahan Wrist Shot | |
| 1st 10:47 | TOR | Shot | #18 M. Brown Wrist Shot | |
| 1st 11:52 | TOR | Shot | #81 P. Kessel Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 12:33 | TOR | Hit | #18 M. Brown hit #94 D. Boogaard | |
| 1st 12:44 | TOR | Penalty | #18 M. Brown Fighting against #8 B. Prust | |
| 1st 12:44 | NYR | Penalty | #8 B. Prust Fighting against #18 M. Brown | |
| 1st 12:49 | TOR | Hit | #3 D. Phaneuf hit #17 B. Dubinsky | |
| 1st 12:59 | TOR | Hit | #3 D. Phaneuf hit #17 B. Dubinsky | |
| 1st 13:39 | NYR | Shot | #10 M. Gaborik Snap Shot | |
| 1st 13:55 | TOR | Shot | #42 T. Bozak Wrist Shot | |
| 1st 14:14 | NYR | Hit | #19 R. Fedotenko hit #36 C. Gunnarsson | |
| 1st 14:43 | NYR | Hit | #5 D. Girardi hit #16 C. MacArthur | |
| 1st 15:05 | NYR | Hit | #22 B. Boyle hit #11 F. Sjostrom | |
| 1st 15:13 | NYR | Hit | #22 B. Boyle hit #9 C. Armstrong | |
| 1st 15:24 | TOR | Hit | #3 D. Phaneuf hit #94 D. Boogaard | |
| 1st 15:49 | TOR | Hit | #11 F. Sjostrom hit #33 M. Rozsival | |
| 1st 15:59 | TOR | Hit | #2 L. Schenn hit #17 B. Dubinsky | |
| 1st 16:30 | NYR | Hit | #17 B. Dubinsky hit #15 T. Kaberle | |
| 1st 16:37 | TOR | Shot | #81 P. Kessel Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 16:41 | TOR | Shot | #81 P. Kessel Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 16:57 | TOR | Shot | #8 M. Komisarek Slap Shot | |
| 1st 17:25 | NYR | Hit | #4 M. Del Zotto hit #16 C. MacArthur | |
| 1st 17:58 | NYR | Penalty | #44 S. Eminger Roughing against #11 F. Sjostrom | |
| 1st 18:03 | TOR | Shot | #3 D. Phaneuf Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 1st 18:36 | TOR | Shot | #15 T. Kaberle Slap Shot | |
| 1st 19:30 | TOR | Shot | #22 F. Beauchemin Slap Shot | |
| 1st 20:00 | NYR | Penalty | #23 C. Drury Cross checking against #16 C. MacArthur | |
| 2nd 00:09 | NYR | Hit | #5 D. Girardi hit #81 P. Kessel | |
| 2nd 00:33 | NYR | Hit | #5 D. Girardi hit #81 P. Kessel | |
| 2nd 02:04 | TOR | Goal | #16 C. MacArthur (5) Tip-In, Assists: #41 N. Kulemin (3), #2 L. Schenn (3) | |
| 2nd 02:33 | TOR | Penalty | #9 C. Armstrong Boarding against #10 M. Gaborik | |
| 2nd 03:25 | NYR | Hit | #31 A. Frolov hit #36 C. Gunnarsson | |
| 2nd 03:45 | TOR | Hit | #18 M. Brown hit #4 M. Del Zotto | |
| 2nd 04:00 | NYR | Shot | #4 M. Del Zotto Slap Shot saved by #35 J. Giguere | |
| 2nd 04:57 | TOR | Goal | #8 M. Komisarek (1) Wrist Shot, Assists: #81 P. Kessel (2) | |
| 2nd 05:15 | TOR | Hit | #15 T. Kaberle hit #16 S. Avery | |
| 2nd 05:49 | TOR | Shot | #81 P. Kessel Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 06:05 | TOR | Shot | #84 M. Grabovski Tip-In saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 06:48 | TOR | Shot | #3 D. Phaneuf Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 07:16 | NYR | Shot | #22 B. Boyle Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 07:23 | NYR | Penalty | #4 M. Del Zotto Interference against #18 M. Brown | |
| 2nd 07:23 | TOR | Penalty | #18 M. Brown Unsportsmanlike conduct against #4 M. Del Zotto | |
| 2nd 07:50 | TOR | Goal | #81 P. Kessel (3) Snap Shot, Assists: #42 T. Bozak (2) | |
| 2nd 08:51 | TOR | Shot | #32 K. Versteeg Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 09:01 | TOR | Hit | #41 N. Kulemin hit #17 B. Dubinsky | |
| 2nd 09:17 | TOR | Shot | #41 N. Kulemin Slap Shot | |
| 2nd 09:26 | NYR | Hit | #18 M. Staal hit #84 M. Grabovski | |
| 2nd 09:56 | NYR | Penalty | #16 S. Avery Roughing against #9 C. Armstrong | |
| 2nd 11:01 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #84 M. Grabovski | |
| 2nd 11:12 | TOR | Hit | #41 N. Kulemin hit #18 M. Staal | |
| 2nd 11:27 | TOR | Hit | #2 L. Schenn hit #19 R. Fedotenko | |
| 2nd 11:41 | TOR | Shot | #16 C. MacArthur Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 12:05 | NYR | Hit | #8 B. Prust hit #2 L. Schenn | |
| 2nd 12:12 | TOR | Shot | #18 M. Brown Backhand saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 2nd 12:21 | NYR | Hit | #97 M. Gilroy hit #9 C. Armstrong | |
| 2nd 12:31 | TOR | Shot | #8 M. Komisarek Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 12:35 | TOR | Shot | #22 F. Beauchemin Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 13:53 | TOR | Hit | #3 D. Phaneuf hit #33 M. Rozsival | |
| 2nd 14:23 | TOR | Shot | #3 D. Phaneuf Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 14:32 | TOR | Hit | #2 L. Schenn hit #8 B. Prust | |
| 2nd 14:47 | NYR | Hit | #8 B. Prust hit #9 C. Armstrong | |
| 2nd 16:04 | TOR | Hit | #8 M. Komisarek hit #21 D. Stepan | |
| 2nd 16:13 | NYR | Shot | #19 R. Fedotenko Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 16:17 | NYR | Hit | #19 R. Fedotenko hit #81 P. Kessel | |
| 2nd 17:10 | NYR | Hit | #22 B. Boyle hit #22 F. Beauchemin | |
| 2nd 17:51 | NYR | Hit | #44 S. Eminger hit #18 M. Brown | |
| 2nd 17:58 | NYR | Hit | #97 M. Gilroy hit #9 C. Armstrong | |
| 2nd 18:30 | TOR | Shot | #37 T. Brent Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 18:30 | NYR | Hit | #16 S. Avery hit #9 C. Armstrong | |
| 2nd 18:38 | NYR | Shot | #21 D. Stepan Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 18:40 | NYR | Hit | #16 S. Avery hit #11 F. Sjostrom | |
| 2nd 18:50 | NYR | Shot | #19 R. Fedotenko Wrist Shot saved by #35 J. Giguere | |
| 2nd 19:52 | NYR | Hit | #33 M. Rozsival hit #41 N. Kulemin | |
| 3rd 00:24 | TOR | Hit | #3 D. Phaneuf hit #16 S. Avery | |
| 3rd 00:49 | TOR | Shot | #2 L. Schenn Wrist Shot | |
| 3rd 01:30 | TOR | Hit | #9 C. Armstrong hit #19 R. Fedotenko | |
| 3rd 02:10 | NYR | Goal | #22 B. Boyle (1) Wrist Shot, Assists: #94 D. Boogaard (1), #44 S. Eminger (1) | |
| 3rd 02:23 | NYR | Hit | #22 B. Boyle hit #2 L. Schenn | |
| 3rd 02:39 | TOR | Penalty | #28 C. Orr Roughing against #22 B. Boyle | |
| 3rd 03:37 | NYR | Hit | #21 D. Stepan hit #9 C. Armstrong | |
| 3rd 03:49 | NYR | Penalty | #19 R. Fedotenko Roughing against #9 C. Armstrong | |
| 3rd 03:49 | NYR | Penalty | #16 S. Avery Slashing against #8 M. Komisarek | |
| 3rd 04:31 | TOR | Shot | #3 D. Phaneuf Snap Shot | |
| 3rd 05:54 | TOR | Shot | #15 T. Kaberle Wrist Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 3rd 06:17 | TOR | Hit | #15 T. Kaberle hit #16 S. Avery | |
| 3rd 06:19 | NYR | Goal | #22 B. Boyle (2) Snap Shot, Assists: #16 S. Avery (4), #4 M. Del Zotto (2) | |
| 3rd 06:31 | NYR | Shot | #42 A. Anisimov Wrap-Around saved by #35 J. Giguere | |
| 3rd 06:41 | TOR | Hit | #16 C. MacArthur hit #42 A. Anisimov | |
| 3rd 07:39 | NYR | Hit | #97 M. Gilroy hit #37 T. Brent | |
| 3rd 08:39 | NYR | Shot | #17 B. Dubinsky Wrist Shot | |
| 3rd 08:47 | NYR | Hit | #18 M. Staal hit #81 P. Kessel | |
| 3rd 09:54 | NYR | Shot | #16 S. Avery Wrist Shot | |
| 3rd 09:54 | TOR | Penalty | #8 M. Komisarek Cross checking against #16 S. Avery | |
| 3rd 10:29 | NYR | Shot | #24 R. Callahan Wrist Shot | |
| 3rd 10:35 | TOR | Hit | #22 F. Beauchemin hit #24 R. Callahan | |
| 3rd 11:05 | NYR | Shot | #42 A. Anisimov Slap Shot | |
| 3rd 11:25 | NYR | Shot | #97 M. Gilroy Wrist Shot saved by #35 J. Giguere | |
| 3rd 13:00 | NYR | Hit | #42 A. Anisimov hit #41 N. Kulemin | |
| 3rd 13:44 | NYR | Shot | #24 R. Callahan Backhand | |
| 3rd 13:58 | NYR | Hit | #16 S. Avery hit #2 L. Schenn | |
| 3rd 14:50 | NYR | Hit | #18 M. Staal hit #32 K. Versteeg | |
| 3rd 15:20 | TOR | Hit | #3 D. Phaneuf hit #31 A. Frolov | |
| 3rd 16:19 | TOR | Shot | #11 F. Sjostrom Wrist Shot | |
| 3rd 16:48 | TOR | Shot | #15 T. Kaberle Slap Shot | |
| 3rd 16:55 | NYR | Hit | #5 D. Girardi hit #84 M. Grabovski | |
| 3rd 16:56 | TOR | Shot | #84 M. Grabovski Wrap-Around saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| 3rd 16:56 | NYR | Penalty | #5 D. Girardi Delaying Game - Puck over glass against #84 M. Grabovski | |
| 3rd 17:54 | NYR | Hit | #44 S. Eminger hit #84 M. Grabovski | |
| 3rd 18:08 | NYR | Hit | #44 S. Eminger hit #41 N. Kulemin | |
| 3rd 18:43 | TOR | Hit | #84 M. Grabovski hit #33 M. Rozsival | |
| 3rd 19:22 | TOR | Hit | #9 C. Armstrong hit #16 S. Avery | |
| 3rd 19:43 | NYR | Shot | #8 B. Prust Tip-In saved by #35 J. Giguere | |
| 3rd 19:58 | NYR | Hit | #8 B. Prust hit #9 C. Armstrong | |
| OT 00:29 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #3 D. Phaneuf | |
| OT 01:35 | NYR | Hit | #19 R. Fedotenko hit #9 C. Armstrong | |
| OT 01:48 | TOR | Shot | #3 D. Phaneuf Slap Shot saved by #30 H. Lundqvist | |
| OT 02:00 | NYR | Shot | #18 M. Staal Wrist Shot | |
| OT 02:36 | NYR | Shot | #5 D. Girardi Wrist Shot | |
| OT 02:48 | NYR | Penalty | #18 M. Staal Interference against #37 T. Brent | |
| OT 03:08 | TOR | Goal | #81 P. Kessel (4) Wrist Shot, Assists: #42 T. Bozak (3), #15 T. Kaberle (3) | |
