| 1st 00:42 | NYR | Hit | #18 M. Staal hit #18 N. Horton | |
| 1st 01:14 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #18 R. Dvorak | |
| 1st 01:27 | NYR | Hit | C. Drury hit #0 S. Reinprecht | |
| 1st 01:36 | FLA | Hit | #28 B. McCabe hit #81 E. Lisin | |
| 1st 01:59 | NYR | Shot | #15 P. Parenteau Snap Shot | |
| 1st 02:23 | FLA | Hit | #23 K. McArdle hit #16 S. Avery | |
| 1st 02:31 | FLA | Hit | #44 D. Seidenberg hit #4 M. Del Zotto | |
| 1st 02:57 | NYR | Shot | #22 V. Prospal Wrist Shot | |
| 1st 03:16 | NYR | Shot | #10 M. Gaborik Wrist Shot | |
| 1st 03:19 | NYR | Hit | #20 C. Higgins hit #4 K. Ballard | |
| 1st 03:33 | FLA | Hit | #4 K. Ballard hit #20 C. Higgins | |
| 1st 04:44 | NYR | Hit | #22 B. Boyle hit #55 B. Allen | |
| 1st 04:50 | FLA | Hit | #38 V. Oreskovich hit #6 W. Redden | |
| 1st 05:23 | NYR | Hit | #81 E. Lisin hit #18 R. Dvorak | |
| 1st 05:30 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #44 D. Seidenberg | |
| 1st 05:42 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #85 R. Olesz | |
| 1st 06:47 | NYR | Shot | #15 P. Parenteau Slap Shot | |
| 1st 08:32 | FLA | Penalty | #33 J. Leopold Tripping against #81 E. Lisin | |
| 1st 08:56 | NYR | Shot | #4 M. Del Zotto Slap Shot | |
| 1st 09:59 | FLA | Shot | #18 D. Moore Wrist Shot | |
| 1st 10:03 | NYR | Hit | #20 C. Higgins hit #18 R. Dvorak | |
| 1st 10:53 | NYR | Hit | C. Drury hit #44 D. Seidenberg | |
| 1st 11:36 | NYR | Hit | #22 V. Prospal hit #33 J. Leopold | |
| 1st 12:25 | FLA | Hit | #18 S. Matthias hit #22 V. Prospal | |
| 1st 12:32 | NYR | Hit | #16 S. Avery hit #4 K. Ballard | |
| 1st 13:39 | NYR | Hit | #22 B. Boyle hit #18 D. Moore | |
| 1st 13:51 | NYR | Shot | #22 B. Boyle Deflection | |
| 1st 14:05 | NYR | Hit | #18 M. Staal hit #18 N. Horton | |
| 1st 14:25 | NYR | Penalty | #24 R. Callahan Slashing against #18 N. Horton | |
| 1st 15:12 | NYR | Hit | #5 D. Girardi hit #18 N. Horton | |
| 1st 17:12 | NYR | Penalty | #10 M. Gaborik Slashing against #18 R. Dvorak | |
| 1st 17:26 | NYR | Hit | #5 D. Girardi hit #7 D. Kulikov | |
| 1st 17:54 | NYR | Shot | #20 C. Higgins Wrist Shot | |
| 1st 18:03 | NYR | Shot | #22 B. Boyle Wrist Shot | |
| 1st 19:21 | FLA | Shot | #28 K. Kreps Tip-In | |
| 1st 19:38 | NYR | Hit | #4 M. Del Zotto hit #23 K. McArdle | |
| 1st 19:58 | NYR | Hit | #16 S. Avery hit #55 B. Allen | |
| 2nd 00:38 | FLA | Shot | #33 J. Leopold Slap Shot | |
| 2nd 00:49 | NYR | Shot | C. Drury Snap Shot | |
| 2nd 01:02 | FLA | Hit | #55 B. Allen hit #81 E. Lisin | |
| 2nd 01:55 | FLA | Hit | #23 K. McArdle hit #5 D. Girardi | |
| 2nd 02:02 | NYR | Hit | #5 D. Girardi hit #23 K. McArdle | |
| 2nd 02:14 | FLA | Shot | #28 K. Kreps Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 02:36 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #55 B. Allen | |
| 2nd 03:03 | FLA | Hit | #18 N. Horton hit #81 E. Lisin | |
| 2nd 03:09 | FLA | Shot | #7 D. Kulikov Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 03:46 | NYR | Shot | #22 V. Prospal Slap Shot | |
| 2nd 04:02 | NYR | Shot | #97 M. Gilroy Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 04:05 | NYR | Hit | #22 V. Prospal hit #44 D. Seidenberg | |
| 2nd 04:07 | NYR | Shot | #97 M. Gilroy Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 04:43 | FLA | Penalty | #28 B. McCabe Hi-sticking against #16 S. Avery | |
| 2nd 05:33 | FLA | Shot | #55 B. Allen Slap Shot | |
| 2nd 05:46 | FLA | Hit | #55 B. Allen hit #97 M. Gilroy | |
| 2nd 06:04 | NYR | Shot | #15 P. Parenteau Slap Shot | |
| 2nd 07:22 | NYR | Penalty | #22 B. Boyle Tripping against #0 S. Reinprecht | |
| 2nd 08:21 | FLA | Shot | #28 B. McCabe Slap Shot | |
| 2nd 09:33 | NYR | Hit | #22 B. Boyle hit #44 D. Seidenberg | |
| 2nd 10:11 | FLA | Hit | #38 V. Oreskovich hit #42 A. Anisimov | |
| 2nd 10:25 | NYR | Shot | #42 A. Anisimov Snap Shot | |
| 2nd 10:46 | FLA | Penalty | #33 S. MacIntyre Fighting against D. Brashear | |
| 2nd 10:46 | NYR | Penalty | D. Brashear Fighting against #33 S. MacIntyre | |
| 2nd 12:19 | NYR | Hit | #5 D. Girardi hit #67 M. Frolik | |
| 2nd 13:40 | FLA | Shot | #85 R. Olesz Snap Shot | |
| 2nd 13:47 | FLA | Shot | #18 R. Dvorak Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 13:49 | NYR | Hit | #4 M. Del Zotto hit #85 R. Olesz | |
| 2nd 14:13 | FLA | Hit | #4 K. Ballard hit #10 M. Gaborik | |
| 2nd 14:36 | FLA | Hit | #18 D. Moore hit #22 V. Prospal | |
| 2nd 14:54 | FLA | Shot | #18 N. Horton Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 16:00 | NYR | Shot | #20 C. Higgins Wrist Shot | |
| 2nd 16:08 | FLA | Shot | #18 R. Dvorak Slap Shot | |
| 2nd 16:41 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #55 B. Allen | |
| 2nd 17:08 | FLA | Hit | #28 B. McCabe hit #16 S. Avery | |
| 2nd 17:45 | FLA | Penalty | #44 D. Seidenberg Interference against #42 A. Anisimov | |
| 2nd 19:35 | NYR | Goal | #10 M. Gaborik (16) Tip-In, Assists: C. Drury (5), #16 S. Avery (6) | |
| 2nd 19:46 | FLA | Shot | #38 V. Oreskovich Snap Shot | |
| 2nd 19:50 | NYR | Shot | #5 D. Girardi Snap Shot | |
| 2nd 19:59 | FLA | Shot | #33 J. Leopold Wrist Shot | |
| 3rd 01:06 | FLA | Shot | #85 R. Olesz Backhand | |
| 3rd 02:40 | NYR | Hit | #22 B. Boyle hit #44 D. Seidenberg | |
| 3rd 03:06 | NYR | Shot | #22 B. Boyle Wrist Shot | |
| 3rd 04:07 | FLA | Shot | #67 M. Frolik Slap Shot | |
| 3rd 05:36 | FLA | Hit | #38 V. Oreskovich hit #22 V. Prospal | |
| 3rd 05:40 | FLA | Penalty | #38 V. Oreskovich Fighting against #97 M. Gilroy | |
| 3rd 05:40 | NYR | Penalty | #97 M. Gilroy Instigator against #38 V. Oreskovich | |
| 3rd 05:40 | NYR | Penalty | #97 M. Gilroy Fighting against #38 V. Oreskovich | |
| 3rd 07:47 | NYR | Penalty | #22 V. Prospal Interference against #0 S. Reinprecht | |
| 3rd 08:38 | NYR | Hit | #32 M. Rozsival hit #9 S. Weiss | |
| 3rd 09:34 | FLA | Shot | #9 S. Weiss Slap Shot | |
| 3rd 10:07 | FLA | Hit | #28 K. Kreps hit #18 M. Staal | |
| 3rd 10:13 | FLA | Shot | #33 J. Leopold Slap Shot | |
| 3rd 10:29 | FLA | Shot | #18 R. Dvorak Wrist Shot | |
| 3rd 11:34 | FLA | Shot | #4 K. Ballard Wrist Shot | |
| 3rd 12:04 | NYR | Shot | #20 C. Higgins Wrist Shot | |
| 3rd 12:36 | FLA | Shot | #18 R. Dvorak Wrist Shot | |
| 3rd 12:44 | NYR | Shot | #24 R. Callahan Slap Shot | |
| 3rd 13:06 | NYR | Shot | #42 A. Anisimov Wrist Shot | |
| 3rd 13:46 | FLA | Shot | #0 S. Reinprecht Wrist Shot | |
| 3rd 14:03 | FLA | Shot | #18 S. Matthias Wrist Shot | |
| 3rd 14:26 | NYR | Hit | #81 E. Lisin hit #55 B. Allen | |
| 3rd 15:07 | FLA | Goal | #18 D. Moore (2) Wrist Shot, Assists: none | |
| 3rd 16:41 | NYR | Hit | #24 R. Callahan hit #18 D. Moore | |
| 3rd 17:12 | FLA | Hit | #28 B. McCabe hit #24 R. Callahan | |
| 3rd 17:48 | FLA | Hit | #23 K. McArdle hit #32 M. Rozsival | |
| 3rd 18:42 | FLA | Shot | #9 S. Weiss Slap Shot | |
| 3rd 19:46 | FLA | Shot | #67 M. Frolik Wrist Shot | |
| OT 00:30 | NYR | Shot | #10 M. Gaborik Wrist Shot | |
| OT 00:36 | NYR | Shot | #32 M. Rozsival Slap Shot | |
| OT 00:39 | FLA | Penalty | #18 R. Dvorak Hi-sticking against #24 R. Callahan | |
| OT 01:18 | NYR | Shot | #10 M. Gaborik Slap Shot | |
| OT 01:57 | NYR | Shot | #10 M. Gaborik Slap Shot | |
| OT 02:10 | NYR | Shot | C. Drury Slap Shot | |
| OT 02:34 | FLA | Hit | #44 D. Seidenberg hit #10 M. Gaborik | |
| OT 03:40 | FLA | Shot | #85 R. Olesz Tip-In | |
| OT 04:00 | NYR | Shot | #15 P. Parenteau Wrist Shot | |
| OT 04:33 | NYR | Shot | #10 M. Gaborik Wrist Shot | |
| OT 04:41 | NYR | Hit | #32 M. Rozsival hit #18 N. Horton | |
| OT 04:48 | NYR | Hit | #22 V. Prospal hit #4 K. Ballard | |
| OT 05:00 | FLA | Shot | #18 D. Moore Wrist Shot | |
| Shootout | FLA | Shot | #18 N. Horton Wrist Shot | |
| Shootout | NYR | Shot | #10 M. Gaborik Wrist Shot | |
| Shootout | FLA | Shot | #0 S. Reinprecht Snap Shot | |
| Shootout | NYR | Goal | #15 P. Parenteau - Wrist Shot | |
| Shootout | FLA | Shot | #9 S. Weiss Backhand | |