Umberger left the ice early during the morning skate, putting his status in doubt to play.
"He'll be a game-time decision, but we're expecting him to play," Blue Jackets coach Todd Richards said.
Umberger, 31, has been a steady producer for the Blue Jackets this season with 16 goals and 31 points in 60 games. He's slated to be on a line with Brandon Dubinsky and Cam Atkinson. If he winds up out of the lineup, Corey Tropp or Blake Comeau would jump into the lineup.
Columbus heads into the game having won both prior meetings against Toronto this season and by sizable margins.
The Blue Jackets took a 5-2 decision at home on Oct. 25 and blew out the Maple Leafs in Toronto 6-0 on Nov. 25. They're not expecting things to come easy this time around.
"We can't expect anything like that tonight," defenseman James Wisniewski said. "We know how well this team has been playing. They've played great at home. They'll make you pay if you don't come and bring your A-game. We're looking for a hard-nosed battle tonight."
The Maple Leafs have been on a roll lately, going 11-2-3 in the past 16 games. Forwards Phil Kessel and James van Riemsdyk have been a big part of that success, combining for seven goals and eight assists in the past four games.
"You have to make them play in their defensive zone," Wisniewski said. "They don't want to play there. When we get the puck we have to make sure our transitions are sharp and we're not fumbling the puck and turning the puck over and letting them gain all their speed. That's how they make their living, off the transition. If we can make them play in their own zone and come 200 feet, that'll be a benefit to us."
Here are the projected lineups for the Blue Jackets and Maple Leafs: